'Dangerous' Cycling and Operation Grimaldi *UPDATED*

Recently in Manchester, Greater Manchester Police launched Operation Grimaldi

"Operation Grimaldi is clamping down on the number of cyclists involved in collisions and to encourage them to learn how to ‘share the road’ with others safely."

"The operation has been running since the beginning of 2013, focusing on ‘hot spot’ areas where pedal cyclists have been seen using the roads dangerously or irresponsibly."

The traffic network team at Greater Manchester Police has been working along the Oxford Road corridor and Wilmslow Road area of the city centre where a number of collisions have occurred recently. GMP had also received a number of complaints about cyclists failing to stop at red lights and weaving dangerously in and out of traffic."

"The operation has seen 415 fixed penalties issued over 10 days of action spread across five months (February to June 2013) for offences such as running red lights, not having lights fitted, cycling on footpaths and using mobile phones whilst cycling."

I can't help but be annoyed at such a high profile campaign focusing on one particular group who happen to be the most vulnerable and very rarely the cause of any serious traffic incident.

"The study, carried out for the Department for Transport, found that in 2% of cases where cyclists were seriously injured in collisions with other road users police said that the rider disobeying a stop sign or traffic light was a likely contributing factor. Wearing dark clothing at night was seen as a potential cause in about 2.5% of cases, and failure to use lights was mentioned 2% of the time."

and

"The data, which was analysed by the Transport Research Laboratory (TRL), showed that more than a quarter of all cycling deaths in 2005-07 happened when a vehicle ran into the rear of a bike."

I have no problem with targeted campaigns.  In instances where there is a real problem and KSI stats to back it up.  I am completely on board with Drink Drive initiatives around holidays.  This all makes sense, because there is a proven need for this targeted approach.

However, share the road (which this purports to be) campaigns are nothing but divisive if not all Road Users are taught to share.

And then see this report of a cyclist in a similar location (in fact probably travelling to) where Operation Grimaldi happened and read the comments from GMP:

"A gold coloured Toyota Yaris which had mounted the kerb in an effort to pass waiting cars collided into him, forcing the man onto the bonnet of the car," it said. "The victim then fell off and the Yaris drove off without checking on the cyclist’s welfare."

Mounted the kerb to pass waiting cars! 

Then forcing the man onto his bonnet????? 

WTF???? He didn't force him onto his bonnet!  He ran the poor fucker over!  Can you imagine using this sort of language if it were a child walking along the pavement?

The driver of the car, couldn't be arsed to wait so forced the child onto his bonnet.

and to tip it off:

"“His impatience meant he had little regard for other road users and we therefore need to catch him as soon as possible."

So really its not his terrible, possibly fatal driving that is at fault? Its the fact he is impatient?  Fucking hell, there is a time bomb waiting to happen. 

What next? A GMP campaign against impatient motoring?

I bet that would result in more than 400 fixed penalty notices.....



**********UPDATE******************

I have had a response to my FOI request from GMP

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST REFERENCE NO: 2358/13

I write in connection with your request for information dated 02/07/2013, which was received by Greater Manchester Police on 02/07/2013 and for which clarification was received on 11/07/2013.  I note you seek access to the following information:

1 - Please can you tell me the KSI figures for cyclists on which you based Operation Grimaldi?

2 - How many people have been injured by 'dangerous cycling' in the Greater Manchester Area?

***Clarification***

As referenced in your press release here http://www.gmp.police.uk/content/WebsitePages/ED5624DA2EE3596880257B98002C2549?OpenDocument  

3 - Are you able to  tell me figures for 2011 and 2012 for other road users killed or seriously injured in accidents caused by cyclists in the Greater Manchester area?

Following receipt of your request searches were conducted within Greater Manchester Police to locate information relevant to your request.  I can confirm that the information you have requested is held, in part, by Greater Manchester Police, (GMP).

The inception of Operation Grimaldi was not based on KSI figures, therefore re point 1 – information is not held in the format requested.  However please see the below in response to the whole of your request.

This year GMP have recorded 18 fatal collisions to date with regard to this request, of these one was a pedestrian that was hit by a pedal cycle.

Whilst fortunately there has been no fatal collisions involving a rider of a pedal cyclist this year there has been five serious and life changing cycle collisions, one incident when a rider rode through a red light and was hit by a vehicle, another where a cyclist rode from the pavement under the rear wheels of a HGV and one where a cyclist placed themselves in the blind spot of a HGV vehicle.

There will be many incidents that do not involve injury and as such are not reported to GMP.

Our priority is to reduce KSI (killed and serious injuries) on the roads of Greater Manchester. This involves educating all road users.  The aim of the operation Grimaldi is to educate all road users.

GMP recognises that the stopping of cyclists has brought the topic high on the agenda and highlighting concerns which may educate or make other road users aware of each other and hopefully alter road usage behaviour.

Unfortunately a large number of the collisions that occur are where cyclists unknowingly place themselves in dangerous positions and situations on the road especially when near to HGV's and busses.  The most common cause of collisions is cyclists entering the road from the pavement.

GMP recognises that the drivers of vehicles do make contact with the cyclist there are many, many times where the cyclist places themselves in a situation be it jumping the red light, manoeuvring in the road without checking over their shoulder or changing direction without indicating which leaves them very vulnerable.

From cyclists who have attended GMPs presentation 93% have had no training what so ever nor are they holders of any licence and such cyclists take to some of the busiest roads in the country and following what they see as 'normal' place themselves in danger.

The main Oxford and Wilmslow Road corridor is the area that has the highest collisions within Greater Manchester and this is why this area has been chosen at this time.

GMP is also introducing those who are vulnerable to take up the free offer of cycle training at betterbycyle phone 0300 123 1675 or through www.tfgm.com/cycling.

Additionally GMP can provide the below statistics that represent all forcewide pedal cycle collisions/casualties:

Severity	2008	2009	2010	2011	2012	2013
Collisions
Fatal	4	2	3	5	1	1
Serious	88	85	117	101	104	31
KSI	92	87	120	106	105	32
Casualties
Fatal	4	2	3	5	1	1
Serious	88	85	118	101	105	31
KSI	92	87	121	106	106	32

Complaint Rights

Your attention is drawn to the attached sheet, which details your right of complaint.

Should you have any further inquiries concerning this matter, please write or contact me on telephone number 0161 856 2529 quoting the reference number above.

Yours sincerely

  

Philip Humphreys

Information Compliance & Records Management Assistant

OK so, some points. I am sure there are many more, but a couple of things struck me.

Firstly, they admit Operation Grimaldi is not based on any real tangible KSI statistics on cyclists endangering other road users.

Secondly, of the fatalities they do mention one is "of these one was a pedestrian that was hit by a pedal cycle". I find this deeply deeply disturbing.  This collision happened on a pedestrian crossing and the cyclist was found to be not at fault.  But including it here suggests otherwise. 'Some rogue cyclist was responsible for killing someone hence we are cracking down on the misbehaviour'.

Thirdly, excuse my maths, I only total 16 since 2008. 2.6 per year. I wonder what the figure is for motorists? I cant see that 2.6 deaths albeit terrible, each one, is really demonstrating the need for such a costly and high profile 'stunt'.

And fourthly, "From cyclists who have attended GMPs presentation 93% have had no training what so ever nor are they holders of any licence" whoooaaahhhhhh now we are getting somewhere. This old chestnut. Do GMP have a subscription for the Daily Mail?   

I am interested how they think licensing might work.  Are they going to now be the Manchester equivalent to the DVLA for cyclists?

Well done GMP. You have completely missed the point. What a wasted opportunity.  Maybe lend a hand at Nice Way Code. They are doing a great job of making a pigs ear of it too.